Title: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 28, 2009, 12:54:06 AM I live in an area where frequent power problems occur. We either have brownouts or blackouts on a consistant basis and it's been a concern of mine for awhile, on how it could potentially harm my S+. I had a few APC Uninterruptible power supply (UPS) units around the house and decided to hook the S+ to it. It works great but it does something weird when it's on battery backup. I have one of those illuminated stickers on the front of the machine, the one that says this machine accepts $1 $5 etc. that light up when the machine is not being used. When you play the machine, the lights go off while the reels are spinning, then come back on after they stop. When I unplug the battery backup and the machine is running off the UPS battery, the sticker that lights up on the front of the machine never goes off. You can be playing the machine and the illuminated sticker just keeps going, never stopping when you hit the spin button, like it does when it's not on battery backup power. Does anyone know if this should be a concern or not and would you recommend an S+ being plugged into one of these UPS battery backup/surge protector units? Thanks!!
Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: stayouttadabunker on November 28, 2009, 01:23:50 AM I think you'll be okay but I would set a multimeter to AC voltage over 200 and
check the UPS's outlets to by themeselves without your slot plugged in to it. Check the UPS strip plugged into an outlet, take some numbers down on a piece of paper, then check it again unplugged into the wall and see if they're all reading the same on your multimeter. If the strips is a lot lower on the meter when uplugged from the wall, I'd say the UPS's power battery is going bad. How old is it and have you ever used the UPS as a power source outside in the cold? Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: Thor777 on November 28, 2009, 01:51:55 AM I think you'll be okay but I would set a multimeter to AC voltage over 200 and check the UPS's outlets to by themeselves without your slot plugged in to it. Check the UPS strip plugged into an outlet, take some numbers down on a piece of paper, then check it again unplugged into the wall and see if they're all reading the same on your multimeter. If the strips is a lot lower on the meter when unplugged from the wall, I'd say the UPS's power battery is going bad. How old is it and have you ever used the UPS as a power source outside in the cold? Yea Bunker is right but you also want to look at what the UPS is rated for in AMPS...Most of them can handle a computer and monitor with no problem but might not be able to put out quite enough for a slot in full playing mode with 3 or more reel stepper motors going along with draw from the bill validator, all the pretty lights (a topper?) and maybe a monitor and coin mechanism? (just a thought) :79- Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 28, 2009, 01:52:46 AM I think you'll be okay but I would set a multimeter to AC voltage over 200 and check the UPS's outlets to by themeselves without your slot plugged in to it. Check the UPS strip plugged into an outlet, take some numbers down on a piece of paper, then check it again unplugged into the wall and see if they're all reading the same on your multimeter. If the strips is a lot lower on the meter when uplugged from the wall, I'd say the UPS's power battery is going bad. How old is it and have you ever used the UPS as a power source outside in the cold? The UPS battery, I just replaced ten days ago, so I know it's good. I had a load on it just to test it last week and it's holding well. Here is something else that may be causing it, as a similar incident happened with my printer, which I had plugged into this UPS. The UPS I currently have uses a Simulated Sine Wave. I have read that this can cause problems, though small, on some devices and I'm not wondering if the transformer that my illuminated sticker uses is being affected by this. I know you can buy a UPS that uses a Pure Sine Wave, but they are expensive. I'll do some metering on the UPS as you described and see what comes up. Thanks stayouttadabunker!! Also, the UPS I have is a 1000VA and the slot machine is the only thing plugged into it. I did connect the UPS to my laptop and used the software to see how big the load was on the UPS from the slot machine. It says it's only using 10% and this is when the reels are spinning and even when the hopper was spitting out quarters. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: stayouttadabunker on November 28, 2009, 02:02:14 AM We had "sine wave" problems at work a couple of weeks ago...
The electricians installed some new wall sockets for a new printing room and the printers/copier machines, even though brand new, were acting funny. We called the power company and some guy that had some equipment that checks HVAC voltages came in and checked everything, he gave the electricians some instructions and pretty soon we were up and running. I wish I would of stuck around to see what the instructions were... I caught a glimpse of a "polarity" conversation but was too busy to engage in it. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 28, 2009, 03:44:34 AM Well, all of the readings are the same, plugged in the wall, the wall and the UPS. I guess S+ machines don't like UPS's or Simulated Sine Wave's for that matter! :33-
Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: westom on November 28, 2009, 12:27:22 PM Well, all of the readings are the same, plugged in the wall, the wall and the UPS. I guess S+ machines don't like UPS's or Simulated Sine Wave's for that matter! Output of most UPSes in battery backup mode is some of the 'dirtiest' electricity that electronics will see. But since all electronics contain significant filtering and surge protection, then that UPS should not cause problems. A UPS output is so 'dirty' as to be harmful to power strip protectors and small electric motors. The resulting 'noise' can interfere with other appliances. For example, it may create noise on longwave (AM) radios. But appreciate the reality. UPSes do not 'clean' electricity. Are designed to power electronics because electronics are some of the most robust appliances.Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 28, 2009, 12:54:20 PM Well, all of the readings are the same, plugged in the wall, the wall and the UPS. I guess S+ machines don't like UPS's or Simulated Sine Wave's for that matter! Output of most UPSes in battery backup mode is some of the 'dirtiest' electricity that electronics will see. But since all electronics contain significant filtering and surge protection, then that UPS should not cause problems. A UPS output is so 'dirty' as to be harmful to power strip protectors and small electric motors. The resulting 'noise' can interfere with other appliances. For example, it may create noise on longwave (AM) radios. But appreciate the reality. UPSes do not 'clean' electricity. Are designed to power electronics because electronics are some of the most robust appliances.Welcome to NLG westom! I agree with you 100% and so does every electronic device I have plugged into a UPS! I notice that "Dirty" power just from the way my computer, printer and slot machine act. I just noticed this tonight. While on battery backup, all of the lights on my S+ seem to dim just a little bit and then go back to their normal brightness when the UPS is back on city power. It's got to be what your saying, because it's putting out the same voltage as our home outlets when on battery backup and the UPS itself is way under it's designed load level. It just seems to make me feel like it's damaging someting but in reality it's probably not. I guess it's better than having my machine go through spikes and drops from our city power and having it do this while were playing it. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: stayouttadabunker on November 28, 2009, 01:42:47 PM Put it this way...
drinking water from a filtered city kitchen faucet or drinking water directly from a mountain stream with your cupped hands. They're both water but taste way different! Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 28, 2009, 06:10:16 PM Put it this way... drinking water from a filtered city kitchen faucet or drinking water directly from a mountain stream with your cupped hands. They're both water but taste way different! Well Put stayouttadabunker!! The mystery as to why this is happening has been solved and the credit goes to stayouttadabunker! My Dad, who of course is a licensed master electrician, wasn't home at the time of this problem, but I explained to him what was taking place. After he arrived, he checked the UPS with his $600 meter and it's only putting out 100 Volts when on battery power. All I had at the time was my $25 meter and of course, you guessed it, was reading 124 Volts, showing me just what I WANTED to see and not actually metering anything correctly. Both the UPS and my $25 meter are now ready for the trash! The battery in the UPS is showing good, so there must be something wrong with the UPS itself. Nonetheless, everybody who posted on this thread was correct in every way. The power is dirty, it's also WAY TOO LOW to be used for anything and all coming from a UPS that's doing a half ass job to begin with! Me and my S+ thank you all for your great advise on this matter! I'm going to go find another UPS that I have somewhere around here and see if it too want's to join it's brother and my $25 meter in the trash can! :72- Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: brichter on November 28, 2009, 06:28:05 PM While on battery backup, all of the lights on my S+ seem to dim just a little bit and then go back to their normal brightness when the UPS is back on city power. You may notice this even with a new UPS. That's because a simulated sine wave has slightly lower voltage peaks. Because the peak voltage is less but there's no time spent ramping from zero to low or high, the useful power (the area "under the curve") is the same. You perceive the effect of less peak voltage as the lights being slightly dimmer. The reason they use a modified sine wave (or even worse, a square wave), is because it's so expensive to use digital electronics to create a true sine wave. Note that back in the day, electronics were much more susceptible to exhibiting bad behavior when powered by simulated sine wave power sources, because the filtering wasn't as good. You young kids have it good nowadays. :200- :200- :72- :72- :72- <edit> the reason your $25 meter wasn't showing an issue is because it doesn't calculate True RMS voltage. You can buy meters that do, but they're more expensive. Or, you can buy a DSO and see it for yourself, but that'll cost you thousands of $$. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: westom on November 28, 2009, 09:14:32 PM You may notice this even with a new UPS. That's because a simulated sine wave has slightly lower voltage peaks. I'm looking at the output of this cheap UPS output on an oscilloscope. 120 volts is two 200 volt square waves with a spike of up to 270 volts between those square waves. Yes, this is also called a sine wave - modified or what every fancy adjective the sales promoters put to it. A square wave is only a sum of sine waves. Also why UPS outputs in battery backup mode can be harmful to some small motors.Reality. 'Cleanest' electricity is obvious - when the UPS is not in battery backup mode. When the load is connected by that UPS directly to AC mains. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 28, 2009, 09:27:17 PM While on battery backup, all of the lights on my S+ seem to dim just a little bit and then go back to their normal brightness when the UPS is back on city power. You may notice this even with a new UPS. That's because a simulated sine wave has slightly lower voltage peaks. Because the peak voltage is less but there's no time spent ramping from zero to low or high, the useful power (the area "under the curve") is the same. You perceive the effect of less peak voltage as the lights being slightly dimmer. The reason they use a modified sine wave (or even worse, a square wave), is because it's so expensive to use digital electronics to create a true sine wave. Note that back in the day, electronics were much more susceptible to exhibiting bad behavior when powered by simulated sine wave power sources, because the filtering wasn't as good. You young kids have it good nowadays. :200- :200- :72- :72- :72- <edit> the reason your $25 meter wasn't showing an issue is because it doesn't calculate True RMS voltage. You can buy meters that do, but they're more expensive. Or, you can buy a DSO and see it for yourself, but that'll cost you thousands of $$. Ok, you got me curious now! I have a UPS that without a doubt, is built much better than the one I plugged my S+ in, allbeit it's still a modified sine wave one. I metered it once again with my little $25 meter. On battery backup, it reads 120 Volts. Used my Dad's meter and it reads 120 Volts. Would it be safe to say that the UPS that reads 100 Volts is messed up somehow? Just asking before I chuck it in the trash. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: stayouttadabunker on November 28, 2009, 09:31:11 PM Maybe the store will take it back?
Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: westom on November 28, 2009, 10:04:05 PM Used my Dad's meter and it reads 120 Volts. Would it be safe to say that the UPS that reads 100 Volts is messed up somehow? Just asking before I chuck it in the trash. Appreciate (learn) how meters work. Does his meter measure RMS? RMS is a concept also learned in high school calculus. Does the meter measure RMS or voltage of only the lower frequency components or voltage peaks? Each may produce a same number OR different numbers depending on the AC voltage waveform.Meanwhile, that 200 volt square wave (output by a typicaly UPS when in battery backup mode) might also (accurately) measure 120 Volts on an RMS meter. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 28, 2009, 10:27:41 PM Used my Dad's meter and it reads 120 Volts. Would it be safe to say that the UPS that reads 100 Volts is messed up somehow? Just asking before I chuck it in the trash. Appreciate (learn) how meters work. Does his meter measure RMS? RMS is a concept also learned in high school calculus. Does the meter measure RMS or voltage of only the lower frequency components or voltage peaks? Each may produce a same number OR different numbers depending on the AC voltage waveform.Meanwhile, that 200 volt square wave (output by a typicaly UPS when in battery backup mode) might also (accurately) measure 120 Volts on an RMS meter. No, his doesn't measure RMS. He did mention that the readings could be off, due to the nature of UPS's and his meter's ability to read it. We did try this though. We plugged a 100 Watt bulb into the UPS in question. Then plugged that same bulb into the other UPS. Sure enough, the UPS that we think is bad, had a much dimmer bulb compared to the other UPS. I even changed batteries in both UPS's and it's still doing the same thing. I'm convinced this UPS is malfunctioning somehow and I'm going to contact the manufacture about this problem and see what they say. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: brichter on November 28, 2009, 10:44:38 PM Is that UPS really outputting a square wave? A square wave spends no time at zero between the high and low portions of the wave, a simulated sine will spend a noticeable amount of time on the zero graticule of the scope.
Here's a good example: Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: westom on November 28, 2009, 10:50:14 PM No, his doesn't measure RMS. He did mention that the readings could be off, due to the nature of UPS's and his meter's ability to read it. Which is what my post also said technically. Light bulb intensity would indicate an RMS voltage differences. A "non-RMS" meter might measure both voltages equal when the light bulb also reports a voltage difference. And neither is incorrect. Both are reporting same things (when meter reports same number while light bulb shows different intensities).Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 28, 2009, 10:51:33 PM Is that UPS really outputting a square wave? A square wave spends no time at zero between the high and low portions of the wave, a simulated sine will spend a noticeable amount of time on the zero graticule of the scope. Here's a good example: The Spec. sheet on both of my UPS's claim that it's using a Simulated Sine Wave. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: westom on November 28, 2009, 10:54:12 PM Is that UPS really outputting a square wave? A square wave spends no time at zero between the high and low portions of the wave, ... Your square wave (as pictured) is only sums of sine waves. A square wave is also a simulated or modified square wave. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 28, 2009, 10:54:41 PM No, his doesn't measure RMS. He did mention that the readings could be off, due to the nature of UPS's and his meter's ability to read it. Which is what my post also said technically. Light bulb intensity would indicate an RMS voltage differences. A "non-RMS" meter might measure both voltages equal when the light bulb also reports a voltage difference. And neither is incorrect. Both are reporting same things (when meter reports same number while light bulb shows different intensities).Damn $1.00 light bulb told a better story about this UPS than the $600 meter!! :97- Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: stayouttadabunker on November 28, 2009, 11:05:59 PM LOL...yup!
Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: brichter on November 29, 2009, 12:52:05 AM Is that UPS really outputting a square wave? A square wave spends no time at zero between the high and low portions of the wave, ... Your square wave (as pictured) is only sums of sine waves. A square wave is also a simulated or modified square wave. A modified square wave doesn't meet the definition of a square wave (sorry, I tend to get technical, one of the downfalls of being an engineer :186-). A square wave is defined as a non-sinusoidal waveform that alternates regularly and instantaneously between 2 states (levels). A modified square wave has a measurable time spent at a level which is at the midpoint of the high and low states, so it has 3 states, not 2. :214- <edit> Normally, I wouldn't use the terms level and state interchangeably, but as applied to this discussion they are. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: jdkmunch on November 29, 2009, 12:53:10 AM I hope my $250,000 APC ups at work doesn't throw out dirty power. :60-
Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: brichter on November 29, 2009, 12:59:39 AM I hope my $250,000 APC ups at work doesn't throw out dirty power. :60- It probably doesn't. We have several in some of the buildings at work that don't. Then there are some buildings that do have modified sine UPSes, but those are only used as bridge power until the big diesel generators in the parking lots kick in. Once every 6 months they service the power systems, and they're not allowed any down time unlesss there is a failure. Downtime is considered to be if a single electrical item in the building shuts off. Pretty funny back in the early 2000s when we were having rolling blackouts, nobody wanted to be in a building that had a generator because they didn't have an excuse to go home. :208- :208- :208- :208- :208- Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: jdkmunch on November 29, 2009, 01:02:38 AM I'm going to test it.
You guys are right - I think I remember looking at that graph when apc was installing the system. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 29, 2009, 08:07:42 AM Used my Dad's meter and it reads 120 Volts. Would it be safe to say that the UPS that reads 100 Volts is messed up somehow? Just asking before I chuck it in the trash. Appreciate (learn) how meters work. Does his meter measure RMS? RMS is a concept also learned in high school calculus. Does the meter measure RMS or voltage of only the lower frequency components or voltage peaks? Each may produce a same number OR different numbers depending on the AC voltage waveform.Meanwhile, that 200 volt square wave (output by a typicaly UPS when in battery backup mode) might also (accurately) measure 120 Volts on an RMS meter. westom, you are correct! Just received an E-Mail from APC on True RMS meter and a Non-True RMS meter and here's a short part of that e-mail: Note: This discussion is a result of the fact that a Non-True RMS meter will read anywhere from 80 - 90 Vac from the output of a 120 Vac APC UPS (or 170 - 180 Vac from the output of a 230 Vac APC UPS) producing a stepped approximated sine wave while operating on-battery. This is not an issue when the UPS is operating on-line. So basically my understanding is that, reading my UPS with a regular meter shows 80- 90 volts while on battery power, which it does. So my UPS isn't messed up is it? Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: westom on November 29, 2009, 09:57:06 PM So basically my understanding is that, reading my UPS with a regular meter shows 80- 90 volts while on battery power, which it does. So my UPS isn't messed up is it? To answer your question, this previouisly posted question must be answered.> Does the meter measure RMS or voltage of only the lower frequency components or voltage peaks? IOW is it an RMS multimeter? Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 29, 2009, 10:27:43 PM So basically my understanding is that, reading my UPS with a regular meter shows 80- 90 volts while on battery power, which it does. So my UPS isn't messed up is it? To answer your question, this previouisly posted question must be answered.> Does the meter measure RMS or voltage of only the lower frequency components or voltage peaks? IOW is it an RMS multimeter? No it is not. It is a Simpson 260-8P, which is not a RMS multimeter. Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: Thor777 on November 30, 2009, 12:01:16 AM I see we have become quite involve in this topic here... I am just wondering as to WHY you would need a UPS on a slot machine? :103-
A surge protector I understand but UPS... Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: stayouttadabunker on November 30, 2009, 12:18:10 AM That way he can play while the power is out... :72-
Didn't the "baby boomer" generation start because of numerous power shortages? :96- Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: Thor777 on November 30, 2009, 12:21:44 AM That way he can play while the power is out... :72- Didn't the "baby boomer" generation start because of numerous power shortages? :96- But, But, I thought Slots only mutliply in the DARK! :97- Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: stayouttadabunker on November 30, 2009, 12:25:13 AM Oh yeah! You're right!.... :125- :125- :125- (Mark smacking himself in the head) :25- :25-
Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 30, 2009, 12:31:32 AM That way he can play while the power is out... :72- Didn't the "baby boomer" generation start because of numerous power shortages? :96- But, But, I thought Slots only mutliply in the DARK! :97- :97- Good one Thor777!! I know, I do feel a little guilty about discussing this on NLG and it has drifted off the subject. It's just that where I live, surge protectors don't offer protection from brownouts. For shi*'s and giggles, I hooked up a UPS to my S+ and actually, we had a power failure about three hours ago for 15 minutes. Sure was cool to still play the machine! :89- It's just that I had the wrong impression of what my UPS was doing. I thought it was putting out 90 volts, but westom pointed out that I needed a meter that reads RMS. As of this very moment, I now understand what happened, the UPS is hooked to my S+, pumping out enough volts to keep it running and life is good! My apologies for shooting off the topic. But hey, now we know everything about UPS's and that slots can mutliply in the LIGHT! :72- Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: Thor777 on November 30, 2009, 12:55:10 AM My apologies for shooting off the topic. But hey, now we know everything about UPS's and that slots can mutliply in the LIGHT! :72- We ALL seem to eventually shoot off the topic of most threads, I can be pretty bad about hijacking a thread but I usually don't try to do It untill most of the "topic" discussion is addressed.. :5- Kinda like this one, you guys were "so involved" I didn't dare jump in :5- :5- :5- Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: jay on November 30, 2009, 01:23:53 AM So it begs the question.... are the casinos on UPS ?
It would seem to me that given the power draw they would probably would have a generator backup their power and only use the UPS for bridging.... but it would have to be one hell of a generator to supply the entire casino floor and lighting..... Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: 5 ACES on November 30, 2009, 02:51:03 AM So it begs the question.... are the casinos on UPS ? It would seem to me that given the power draw they would probably would have a generator backup their power and only use the UPS for bridging.... but it would have to be one hell of a generator to supply the entire casino floor and lighting..... I know of a casino around these parts that had 20-30 slot machines on some kind of battery backup/generator, when a bad snow storm hit and caused a blackout. The casino was small in size, I think they had around 200-300 machines, but they did have a few that were still playable during the power outage. It's actually what sparked me to do the same, but my tiny little casino only has 1 machine! :97- Title: Re: Is it safe to use a UPS on an S+? Post by: westom on November 30, 2009, 02:42:47 PM So it begs the question.... are the casinos on UPS ? Generators take time to get up to speed. Facilities that need uninterrupted power must have some power source for about 30 seconds; while the generator starts.Some casino machines use electric motors. Therefore output from a typical plug-in UPS can be harmful. Casinos would also use more expensive technology UPSes that actually output sine waves. How much for a household 'since wave' generating UPS? The $100 UPS must be replaced by a $500 UPS. When selling a UPS to the naive, these manufacturers invent subjective phrases that mean nothing (often to promote myths and half truths) such as modified sine wave, simulated sine wave, etc. Expressions that mean nothing because numbers are not included. If that UPS manufacturer is being honest, provided are numbers such as THD. To promote a scam, a manufacture must have customers not demand numbers. You see it here. So many discussing a UPS in subjective terms. Not quoting numbers from numeric specs. Assuming subjective terms have meaning. Worse, no one got angry because the manufacturer did not provide numbers. Exposed is the subjective ‘modified sine wave’ myth that is created to intentionally deceive. No one got angry once the purpose of that subjective term was exposed. A modified sine wave. What should be a 120 volt sine wave is a 200 volt square wave. If the square wave is properly manipulated (as brichter discussed), then the RMS volt meter will measure that 200 volt square wave as 120 volts. In that example, the modified sine wave also had a spike of up to 270 volts between the square waves. Where is ‘clean’ electricity from a ‘modified sine wave’? The myth promoted only because consumers did not demand numbers. Because consumers gave credence to a subjective term using only feelings. Same UPS that may be ideal to computers (because computers are so robust) can be destructive to refrigerators. If numbers are not provided to expose that reality, then integrity of that UPS manufacturer should be questioned. This discussion without numbers would proobably prmote a scam. |